A Routine Training Flight Off Southern California
On November 14, 2004, the USS Nimitz Carrier Strike Group was conducting routine training exercises in the Pacific Ocean off the coast of Southern California. The day was supposed to be ordinary. It became one of the most famous UFO encounters in modern history — the case now known as the “Tic Tac” incident.
The cruiser USS Princeton, part of the strike group, had been tracking unusual radar contacts for about two weeks. The objects would appear at 80,000 feet, drop rapidly toward the sea, and stop and hover at around 20,000 feet. On the morning of November 14, controllers diverted two F/A-18F Super Hornet fighter jets to investigate.
What the Pilots Saw
Commander David Fravor, commanding officer of Strike Fighter Squadron 41 (VFA-41), the “Black Aces,” flew the lead jet with his weapons systems officer. Lieutenant Commander Alex Dietrich flew as his wingman. When they reached the location, all four aircrew members saw the same thing: a white, oval object hovering above a patch of churning white water, as if something just below the surface was disturbing the sea.
Fravor has described the object in interviews as about 40 feet long, shaped like a Tic Tac mint — smooth, white, and featureless, with no wings, no rotors, no visible engines, and no exhaust. The four aircrew watched it for about five minutes. As Fravor descended for a closer look, the object rose to meet him, mirroring his maneuvers, and then accelerated away and vanished. The disturbance in the water disappeared with it. Radar operators soon picked up the object again, about 60 miles away from where it had been seen.
The Infrared Video
A second wave of fighters launched from the Nimitz later that day. Lieutenant Chad Underwood, whose jet carried an infrared targeting pod, recorded about 76 seconds of infrared footage of an oblong object — the video now known as FLIR1. It is important to note that Underwood’s video was recorded roughly 90 minutes after Fravor’s visual sighting, so the footage and the eyewitness account are two separate pieces of evidence from the same day, not the same moment.
The video remained largely unknown to the public until December 2017, when The New York Times reported on a secret Pentagon UFO program and published the footage. On April 27, 2020, the Pentagon officially released the video, along with two other Navy videos, and confirmed that the footage was authentic — recorded by US Navy personnel.
Read also: Pentagon Releases Three New UAP Videos in PURSUE Release 08 — All Three Listed as Unresolved
Sworn Testimony in Congress
In July 2023, Fravor testified under oath before a US House Oversight subcommittee, describing the object he saw and stressing that it showed flight characteristics he could not explain. His testimony, along with the authenticated video and the radar reports, is why the Nimitz case is still discussed more than 20 years later: it combines trained military witnesses, radar data, and official video in a single incident.
At the same time, the case has limits that are often left out of retellings. Fravor gave no size estimate under oath; the widely quoted 40-foot figure comes from his interviews. Underwood himself has said he could not confirm from his own view that the object in the video accelerated sharply out of frame. And the Pentagon has never said what the object was.
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Date of encounter | November 14, 2004 |
| Location | Pacific Ocean off Southern California |
| Ships involved | USS Nimitz Carrier Strike Group; USS Princeton (CG-59) |
| Lead pilot | Commander David Fravor, VFA-41 “Black Aces” |
| Wingman | Lieutenant Commander Alex Dietrich |
| Object described | White, oval, about 40 feet long (per interviews); no wings, rotors, or exhaust |
| Video | FLIR1, recorded by Lt. Chad Underwood (about 76 seconds) |
| Public release | December 2017 (New York Times); Pentagon release April 27, 2020 |
| Congressional testimony | July 2023, House Oversight subcommittee |
| Official status | Unresolved — listed by AARO as an unresolved case |
What Is Still Unproven
The Nimitz case remains officially unresolved. The Pentagon’s UAP office, AARO, has not identified the object, and no published government file offers proof that it was alien technology. “Unresolved” means the evidence does not identify the object — it is not evidence of extraterrestrial craft.
Researchers have proposed ordinary explanations, including sensor artifacts, parallax effects in the infrared video, and misidentified aircraft or equipment. None of those explanations has been confirmed either, and the witnesses stand by what they reported. That is the honest state of the case: a well-documented encounter with credible witnesses, authenticated video, and radar reports — and still no answer to what the object was.
Read also: The 1953 UFO That Stumped Lockheed’s Kelly Johnson — New Pentagon Files Reopen the Case

