The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) has approached the Supreme Court seeking recall of its September 28 order that exempted current Class 6 students from the three-language policy. In an application filed on Wednesday, November 18, the board argued that the exemption would benefit only 4,186 students — just 0.18 percent of students nationwide — while creating unfairness for 45,000 students who have already opted for two native languages and disrupting academic arrangements in CBSE schools.
The move sets up a fresh round in the legal battle over CBSE’s revised three-language formula, barely seven weeks after the top court extended to Class 6 the same transitional relaxation already available to students in Classes 7, 8 and 9. The court has not yet decided on the recall plea, and until it does, the September 28 order remains in force.
What CBSE told the court
According to reports of the application, CBSE’s central argument is one of numbers. Of the roughly 28 lakh students currently studying in Class 6 in CBSE-affiliated schools, only 4,186 — about 0.18 percent — would actually gain from the exemption, the board has told the court. Against that, the board says the order works against around 45,000 students who have already chosen two native languages under the new framework and made their academic plans accordingly.
CBSE has also argued that the exemption disrupts academic arrangements in schools. Schools have already organised timetables, teachers and textbooks around the three-language structure for the current session, and a mid-year change of this kind forces them to rework those arrangements. The board’s case, in short, is that the relief helps very few students while unsettling many more.
Read also: CBSE Three Language Formula: Rules for Class 6, R1, R2, R3 Explained
What the September 28 order said
On September 28, a bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, along with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, directed CBSE to extend to current Class 6 students the same relaxation already granted to students of Classes 7, 8 and 9. Under that arrangement, Class 6 students continue to study the third language, but they do not have to appear for a CBSE Board examination in that language when they reach Class 10.
The court made it clear that there would be no pass-or-fail consequence attached to the third language under the transitional arrangement. “There will be no pass/failure. There will only be an appearance certificate,” the bench observed. The court also directed CBSE to appoint an officer to reach out to schools that were yet to put the required infrastructure in place and find out the difficulties they faced.
The direction came despite the Centre’s opposition. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the bench that the government was not inclined to exempt Class 6 students this year and that they should pursue the new framework from the current academic year itself. The Centre submitted that about 99 percent of CBSE’s 28,819 schools had adopted the three-language policy and had the necessary facilities, with only about 1.2 percent yet to do so, and that textbooks and learning material were available.
The three-language formula at a glance
CBSE’s revised language framework, introduced through a circular on May 15, 2026, requires students to study three languages, with at least two of them being native Indian languages. The policy is part of the implementation of the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 and the National Curriculum Framework for School Education (NCF-SE) 2023. A CBSE statement on June 29, 2026, clarified the transitional protection for Classes 7, 8 and 9: those students would not have to take a Board examination in the third language in Class 10.
| Language | What it means |
|---|---|
| R1 — First language | The student’s mother tongue or the main medium of instruction |
| R2 — Second language | Another language, which may be an Indian language or English |
| R3 — Third language | An additional language; under the transitional relief, assessed by the school only, with no CBSE Board examination in Class 10 |
Students already studying two non-native languages have been allowed to continue with the same combination and take one additional Bharatiya Bhasha as their third language. The broader petitions challenging the three-language framework itself remain pending before the court, and the September 28 order did not settle that larger question.
Read also: UGC NET December 2026 Exam Dates Out: Subject-Wise Schedule for 87 Subjects
Timeline: how the dispute reached this point
| Date | Development |
|---|---|
| May 15, 2026 | CBSE issues circular introducing the three-language requirement for Classes 6 to 9 |
| June 29, 2026 | CBSE statement: Classes 7, 8 and 9 exempt from a Board examination in the third language in Class 10 |
| August 20, 2026 | Supreme Court asks the Centre to consider sparing Class 6 students a third-language Board exam |
| September 28, 2026 | Supreme Court extends the same relaxation to current Class 6 students |
| November 18, 2026 | CBSE files application seeking recall of the September 28 order |
| Next hearing | Not yet listed; the court will decide when to hear the recall plea |
What happens next
The recall application will come up before the same bench, which will decide whether the September 28 order should stand, be modified or be withdrawn. When the court passed the order in September, it posted the main petitions for hearing after six weeks and asked CBSE to file its reply affidavit within four weeks, with a rejoinder, if any, within two weeks after that. No date has been announced yet for hearing the recall plea itself.
For now, parents and schools should treat the September 28 order as the position in force. Class 6 students continue to study the third language, but under the court’s order they will not face a separate CBSE Board examination in that subject when they reach Class 10, and their promotion or certification cannot be stalled on account of the third-language Board examination. The court had also warned that it would intervene if any school held back a student on account of internal assessment in the third language.

What this means for parents and students
First, nothing changes for Class 6 students today. The exemption granted on September 28 remains valid until the Supreme Court decides the recall application, so families should not change language choices or worry about a Board examination in the third language in Class 10 on the basis of CBSE’s filing alone.
Second, students should keep studying the third language as part of their regular curriculum. The exemption was never about removing the language from studies — it was about the examination consequence. Even under the transitional relief, the third language is assessed internally by the school.
Third, the numbers at the heart of CBSE’s plea show how narrow the dispute has become. Whether 4,186 students is too small a group to justify an exemption, or whether the principle matters regardless of the headcount, is now a question for the court. Its answer will decide whether the current Class 6 batch keeps the same protection as the Classes 7 to 9 batches, or rejoins the full three-language examination framework.
Read also: CBSE Date Sheet 2027: Class 10 and 12 Board Exams From February 16


